Surgeon accused of killing ex-wife and her dentist husband gets first look at Ohio court with legal defense

24 Jan 2026 By foxnews

A surgeon accused of killing his ex-wife and her dentist husband in Ohio has pleaded not guilty after he was extradited to face murder charges.

Michael McKee was arrested Jan. 10 after allegedly shooting and killing Spencer Tepe, 37, and Monique Tepe, 39, in the couple's home in Columbus' Weinland Park neighborhood between 2 a.m. and 5 a.m. Dec. 30. McKee is Monique's ex-husband.

McKee was arrested in Rockford, Illinois, Jan. 10 and booked into the Winnebago County Jail in Illinois, before he was extradited to Columbus, Ohio, where he's being held at the James A. Karnes Corrections Center. He faces upgraded premeditated aggravated murder charges in the deaths of Spencer and Monique.

McKee appeared remotely for an arraignment hearing Tuesday from jail and pleaded not guilty to four charges of premeditated aggravated murder with firearm specifications and aggravated burglary. Three aggravated murder charges include specifications alleging McKee used or displayed an automatic firearm or silencer, and the fourth alleged that a gun was displayed or brandished.

OHIO DENTIST SLAYINGS SUSPECT INDICTED ON MORE AGGRAVATED MURDER, BURGLARY CHARGES

McKee is being represented by attorney Diane Menashe, who manages her own firm and has been a lawyer for 27 years. Menashe previously represented Dr. William Husel, an Ohio doctor who was acquitted of 14 counts of murder after prosecutors alleged he prescribed excessive pain medication to his patients in the Columbus-based Mount Carmel Health System.

Charging documents indicate police were able to identify McKee by linking him to a car that arrived in the Tepes' neighborhood shortly before the murders and left just after the homicides. The car was then located in Rockford, Illinois, and police found evidence it belonged to McKee.

Columbus Police Chief Elaine Bryant earlier told Fox News Digital that several weapons were taken from McKee's property, adding that a preliminary link was established for one of those guns to the murders.

One of Spencer and Monique's friends found the couple dead Dec. 30 at their home, according to a 911 call.

POLICE ARREST EX-HUSBAND OF OHIO WOMAN SLAIN ALONGSIDE DENTIST HUSBAND IN DOUBLE MURDER, RECORDS SHOW

"There's a body," the caller says. "Our friend wasn't answering his phone. We just did a wellness check. We just came here, and he appears dead. He's lying next to his bed, off of his bed in this blood. I can't get closer to seeing more than that."

Monique and McKee were married for seven months after their wedding Aug. 22, 2015, before splitting up, court records show. McKee was completing his residency at the Virginia Tech Carilion Clinic when Monique filed for divorce, writing that the two were "incompatible."

Monique and Spencer's two children were found safe at the home after the shooting. Rob Misleh, Spencer's brother-in-law, told People the couple's 1-year-old child was likely in a crib when the shooting happened.

"[He] was in the crib right, and was unable to get out of the crib on his own, and, also, it was at a time he would've been well awake by this time," he said. "From the timeframe that we know, 2 a.m. to 5 a.m., [when the murders took place], the kids would've been in their beds. So, we assume … they did not see anything."

The couple was preparing to celebrate their five-year wedding anniversary one month before they were killed, Misleh told WSYX.